[Epub] ➤ Beyond Words: What Animals Think and Feel ➥ Carl Safina – Andy-palmer.co.uk

Beyond Words: What Animals Think and Feel Yes I ve read lots on the general subject before And yes this is a long book But I m glad I m making time for it because 1 it s almost like four books in one, with elephants, wolves, and killer whales, plus an intermission to explore the validity of concepts like theory of mind 2 each section has anecdotes science pleas to our humanity 3 it s beautifully written, with a style or voice I ve not noticed in other books, and 4 it s newer than almost anything Yes I ve read lots on the general subject before And yes this is a long book But I m glad I m making time for it because 1 it s almost like four books in one, with elephants, wolves, and killer whales, plus an intermission to explore the validity of concepts like theory of mind mirror neurons etc 2 each section has anecdotes science pleas to our humanity 3 it s beautifully written, with a style or voice I ve not noticed in other books, and 4 it s newer than almost anything else I ve read and therefore gives me new understandings and new shocks at what ppl are still doing to harm animals and ecosystems and, of course, ultimately, ourselves.I m ranking it with my other two very favorite books for laypeople on the broad subject, Some We Love, Some We Hate, Some We Eat Why It s So Hard to Think Straight About Animals and Are We Smart Enough to Know How Smart Animals Are I have given other related titles five stars recommendations, but if you read these three you ll gain the most understanding satisfaction, imo.One thing I do disagree with the author about I m not looking for something that distinguishes humans from other animals because I feel that we re somehow transcendent and I want science to back up my faith in that No, I want to know what about us made us screw up so badly An easy interpretation of the data could be that patriarchy isaggressive, rapacious, and short sighted than matriarchy, so that could be part of our problem Written language might also have something to do with it, I m afraid.Heartbreaking book Dense with concepts and information A read to be savored Let it make an impact on you I m not suggesting that humans and elephants have all the same emotions Self loathing seems uniquely human I ve seen an orangutan string and wear a bead necklace that no one taught her to make Bonobo is pronounced buh NO bo Wolves have been denigrated as wasteful Well, true, those so accused don t return to a carcass No, they have learned that carcasses get poisoned in their absence.Wolves are again fair game in Wyoming No license, no limit, no season By moving out of nature and onto farms, we became in a very real sense just another farm animal Regarding the experiments about whether an animal can recognize itself in a mirror deeply flawed When a bird, say, attacks the mirror, it does so precisely because it believes the reflection is another individual not itself It demonstrates self concept It doesn t fail the mirror test It just doesn t understand reflection A better definition of species is offered here When free living animals freely interbreed, they re the same species According to that definition, there may be about a dozen species of killer whales.Peter Tyack reminds us, There are hundreds of tests for human intelligence alone, but we still have trouble even defining human intelligence Who wasintelligent, Pablo Picasso or Henry Ford And now I get to look through the bibliography Some books will appeal, even though I know that I shouldn t even bother with older books because so much of what we thought we knew is wrong, and so much new stuff is being learned But I ll look anyway And I ll continue to work towards avegan diet, and I ll continue to vote for leaders who vote green, and I ll continue to try to get everyone I know off bottled water and disposable tissues napkins Etc Carl Safina, an author, professor and ecologist, presents us with his newest work Beyond Words What Animals Think and Feel 2015 , shedding some light on the mysteries of animal actions and behaviors within their own societies, and their interactions to the human world as well The book will take the readers in a journey to the forests, valleys and oceans, where they can literally live among the elephants, wolves, dogs, birds, chimpanzees, bats, dolphins and whales The author, and so does th Carl Safina, an author, professor and ecologist, presents us with his newest work Beyond Words What Animals Think and Feel 2015 , shedding some light on the mysteries of animal actions and behaviors within their own societies, and their interactions to the human world as well The book will take the readers in a journey to the forests, valleys and oceans, where they can literally live among the elephants, wolves, dogs, birds, chimpanzees, bats, dolphins and whales The author, and so does the evidence, portray these animals not like any other animals, but as individuals Through a collection of observations by him and his fellow researchers, Safina touches the capability of animals to feel, to sympathize, to grieve, to help and seek help, or even to punish How elephants feel the loss of a beloved, and even cover the corpse of a family member with dirt and tree branches, how the alpha wolf travels to the coyotes den, mascaraing them because they injured her pride, or how female dolphins play some seduction tricks on males to rescue a trapped friend who is not interested in mating with the hungry males, are some of many examples to the existence of conciseness within animal minds Safina also highlights astonishing acts of intelligence that may not cross our minds things we might have thought only us are capable of doing What is really interesting is that those scientists, when explaining how an animal does something, they refer to them with names Ella, Treisa, Grace, or even numbers like 06, or 755 These names obtain, through the chain of events of their lives, certain personalities This is the message the author wants to deliver there is no wolves do this and elephants do that each animal is an individual Some Show toughness, shyness, or laziness, while others are simply playful and joyful THEY ARE DIFFERENT Beyond Words, Readers Travel To Amboseli National Park In The Threatened Landscape Of Kenya And Witness Struggling Elephant Families Work Out How To Survive Poaching And Drought, Then To Yellowstone National Park To Observe Wolves Sort Out The Aftermath Of One Pack S Personal Tragedy, And Finally Plunge Into The Astonishingly Peaceful Society Of Killer Whales Living In The Crystalline Waters Of The Pacific Northwest So often when I recommend a non fiction book I like it because it reads like a novel, and not like a textbook Although textbooks can provide you with a lot of information, often it s difficult to retain because it s just a long list of facts and data and no easy way to have substantial retention This author goes above and beyond anything I ve read from a non fiction book, this not only read like a novel, this read like a poetic work of art Like, this guy rivals Josiah Bancroft with his use of So often when I recommend a non fiction book I like it because it reads like a novel, and not like a textbook Although textbooks can provide you with a lot of information, often it s difficult to retain because it s just a long list of facts and data and no easy way to have substantial retention This author goes above and beyond anything I ve read from a non fiction book, this not only read like a novel, this read like a poetic work of art Like, this guy rivals Josiah Bancroft with his use of simile and metaphor, the way he wrote sucked you into the moments he was living He went to Africa to study with the experts to write this book, and it could not have turned out any better If you have a love of animals, get this book If you ve ever wondered how unique humans are with their emotions, family relations, problem solving, and intelligence get this book If you ve ever sat and admired Discovery Channel, been at the zoo and stared at the animals wondering what they were thinking or feeling, get this book If you ve studied Ethology animal behavior Biology or Zoology and all your life you ve been told it goes against science to anthropomorphize get this book and realize why this is an archaic way of thinking If you believe in evolution, you ll know that nothing just springs out of no where, nature and biology build on itself Yes, there are random mutations, but they are random mutation for pre existing genetic structure A mouse will never randomly mutate and have wings for example., it s not in it s background dna, it s not possible However, sometimes humans are born with tails, because we do evolve from animals that have tails So, where did our emotions come from, where did our intelligence come from It was built off the backbone of evolution, we are not supremely unique in our ability to form bonds with other individuals of the same species We are not unique in our family ties We are not unique with our intellegence We may have capitolized on our large brains in ways other species haven t, but to assume other animals have none of those qualities in any way is ludicrous It was so taboo for the longest time for any animal behaviorist to suggest there were emotions and feelings in other animals it could be a career ending paper to put forth that maybe we aren t alone in this This book explores what possibilities lie in the brains of other animals, and what evidence we have for intelligence in other species Elephants are one of my favorite animals of all time, and this book opens with the author in Africa working with one of the leading experts in the field she s been there for over 40 years and has so much experience it boggles the brain Reading about the herds and how they are structured was so captivating and endearing I was helpless to stop reading, but I wanted to take it slow and absorb every word If you ve never had any of the above interests, pick this book up anyway and find a new passion in life.http weatherwaxreport.blog I think a person s reaction to this book will probably be based on on the style of writing they prefer When I read non fiction I am hoping for a concise and professional approach That doesn t mean that there can t be some humor and some reflection, so long as it doesn t overpower the purpose of the book The author of this book though seems overly concerned with trying to embed his personality into the pages There are constant off the wall reflections and comments, numerous one and two word s I think a person s reaction to this book will probably be based on on the style of writing they prefer When I read non fiction I am hoping for a concise and professional approach That doesn t mean that there can t be some humor and some reflection, so long as it doesn t overpower the purpose of the book The author of this book though seems overly concerned with trying to embed his personality into the pages There are constant off the wall reflections and comments, numerous one and two word sentences, and long circular reflections It felt almost as if I was reading a YouTube video We could remove most of that extra stuff, keep the animal stories and important information, and reduce the book by 50%.That is not to say this was not a good book For those who prefer a muchconversational approach this book may have even been pleasant to read And for anyone interested in animal societies and animal ways of being this book is certainly worth the effort it may take to push through it Otherwise it may be a better idea to watch a PBS Nature special on Netflix Dreadful Contains lines like, One time my friend followed by a claim that this one anecdote tells us something about an entire species Very light on science, heavy on speculation If this were marketed as a book of observations about animals, it might get a higher rating But we were promised an explanation of what animals think and feel, not what the author thinks and feels about animals. Carl Safina prompts readers to consider animal behavior and thought, not by comparing it with human behavior, but by viewing it as unique He encourages marrying science and logic to draw conclusions about animal thoughts and feelings For example, we may think it good science to very detachedly document the way a dog bounds and jumps up to greet us when we return home We can also use logic and apply what we know about this dog and our experiences with feeling to say the dog is happy Major sec Carl Safina prompts readers to consider animal behavior and thought, not by comparing it with human behavior, but by viewing it as unique He encourages marrying science and logic to draw conclusions about animal thoughts and feelings For example, we may think it good science to very detachedly document the way a dog bounds and jumps up to greet us when we return home We can also use logic and apply what we know about this dog and our experiences with feeling to say the dog is happy Major sections include visits with scientists observing elephants, wolves, and killer whales roaming freely in the wild Dogs, parrots, ravens, tigers, humans, monkeys, and many other species get brief mentions Content is mostly anecdotal, relaying Safina s own adventures or those of the long time observers he visits in the field Reading this book is like sitting down with a friend or relative albeit a smart and well traveled one and listening to him philosophize as he recounts experiences in the field with some of the world s leading researchers on the behavior of free roaming animals Safina is entertaining and is not above using some punny humor, particularly in chapter titles Some of the experiences are hard to read nature can be cruel Others are funny Most all are fascinating Generally, I read fiction at a rapid pace and assign myself a set number of daily nonfiction pages, like I would with medication or a homework assignment Beyond Words was highly readable, and I found myself actually wanting to surpass my mandatory quota I finished the book in three sittings, though I did find the prose a bit verbose at times Maybe I would have finished in two, with a bitediting I would have loved to enclose a few quotations from the text to make my points, but could not since I read an advance reader s edition prior to the book s release date Recommended for those interested in animal behavior I took a long time to read Beyond Words, not because I didn t like it but because I had to let each piece sink in We learn so much about animal brains but also much about the human brain The first section will make you fall in love with elephants, so it was hard to read because every time I read the news,elephants had been slain for their ivory Just two days ago I read where six elephants were killed with cyanide, CYANIDE , for their tusks And orcas are so smart, so loving to their fam I took a long time to read Beyond Words, not because I didn t like it but because I had to let each piece sink in We learn so much about animal brains but also much about the human brain The first section will make you fall in love with elephants, so it was hard to read because every time I read the news,elephants had been slain for their ivory Just two days ago I read where six elephants were killed with cyanide, CYANIDE , for their tusks And orcas are so smart, so loving to their families, especially their children, and grieve hardily when one dies or a baby is kidnapped for amusment park shows The military is allowed to bomb in the Olympic Coast Marine Sanctuary Bomb in a sanctuary Every time it happens dead whales are found with hemorrhages all over their bodies But this book is also filled with joy Readers will grow to love the families that are followed here, whales, elephants, and wolves They do think and they are intelligent Beyond Words will make you laugh in delight but will also make you shed a few tears Review to come Do I love it.or do I like it a lot I do definitely want everyone to read this book When I think about the book, I automatically say, I liked that A LOT , so four stars When I chose to read this book I thought I was going to get something like The Genius of Dogs How Dogs Are Smarter than You Think which I gave four stars, but rather than concentrating solely on dogs the focus would cover many animals Carl Safina s book is wider in scope and completely different in focus Review to come Do I love it.or do I like it a lot I do definitely want everyone to read this book When I think about the book, I automatically say, I liked that A LOT , so four stars When I chose to read this book I thought I was going to get something like The Genius of Dogs How Dogs Are Smarter than You Think which I gave four stars, but rather than concentrating solely on dogs the focus would cover many animals Carl Safina s book is wider in scope and completely different in focus Hare s book is very good, but Safina s is better, in my view Hare s book draws conclusions by looking at particular experiments, stipulating how they were carried out and analyzing their results It is a book about the latest scientific studies on dogs cognitive abilities Some of the conclusions drawn in reference to dog behavior are briefly referred to in Safina s book Safina s book is less about scientific experiments Safina s book is based on studies of animals in the wild and the resultant conclusions that can be drawn At first, statements made had me asking, Where is your proof By the end I was totally in sync with what the author was stating There are lengthy sections devoted to the study of elephants, wolves and killer whales, alternately known as orcas Orcinus orca They belong to the dolphin family, are toothed and are its largest member Take one guess what their name implies, yet they do not hurt human beings I found that revealed about the whales and the elephants utterly fascinating That about the wolves I found a bit long winded We follow the fission of a wolf pack There are shorter sections on other, widely varied animals some examples being chimpanzees, bonobos, hyenas, falcons, dogs and bats , the point being to show their emotional and intellectual capacity We are an animal too and we share a common bond The author vividly exemplifies how we are similar and how we differ What is striking are the cognitive and emotional similarities while our outward appearances so differ The author goes a step further and proposes ideas that are controversial on self domestication, anthropomorphism, empathy, intelligence and understanding It is here the book gets MOST interesting Great for lively discussions I like that he steps back and questions where the facts and evidence seem to point while at the same time stressing what remains unknown After reading this book, one look at animals, even insects, fish and turtles with a new perspective It is muchdifficult to be cruel to a thinking and emotional creature Authors should NOT read their own books The author does that here Yes, I could understand what was said, but often he reads too fast Way too fast HE is at home with the ideas presented and to him they are not new Speaking for myself, I had to stop and consider what exactly self domestication implies and what are its consequences There are concepts that must be thought about to fully absorb their significance There is one section concerning some of the author s pet peeves, an example being the mirror mark test, also known as the mirror self recognition test MSR He was so very angry he simply couldn t hold himself back listening became a difficult task It was hard to keep up with him I was also disappointed when different animal calls were spoken In an audiobook it would have been perfect to let us hear them The author is a famed conservationist, a marine biologist and has a PhD in ecology from Rutgers University Reading this book was fascinating due to its depth of information and the wisdom I found in the lines Here is one quote If the world can no longer afford the luxury of natural beauty, then it will be overcome by its ugliness.In an entirely man made world there can be no room for man either.He dares to ask uncomfortable questions about human behavior He shows us the nonsensicality of assumptions we have relied on in the past He shows us that man must begin to work with nature in a moral and ethical manner Humans are human and we are also animals, with our physical lives on a continuum with other animals.Safina is persuasive enough to convince anyone but the most rigid that mere animals share much with us, in terms of intelligence, emotions, sense of humor, and individuality not to mention social groups and ties.I thought it an excellent point that , regarding many of the tests for animal intelligence, etc most humans would not pass them Dogs are stupid because they can be fooled What ab Humans are human and we are also animals, with our physical lives on a continuum with other animals.Safina is persuasive enough to convince anyone but the most rigid that mere animals share much with us, in terms of intelligence, emotions, sense of humor, and individuality not to mention social groups and ties.I thought it an excellent point that , regarding many of the tests for animal intelligence, etc most humans would not pass them Dogs are stupid because they can be fooled What about humans victimized by con artists And, OK, my cat is not going to write a symphony but then, neither am I This book is beautifully written, and brings many of the other denizens of our world alive.Highly recommended, both for people interested in the other animals that share our planet, and for sf authors interested in writing persuasive aliens.I received this book in exchange for writing a fair review, from LibraryThing

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *